What's in a name, you may ask?
Plenty, if you're a car!
Mahindra & Mahindra has just
pulled the covers off its latest project - Ingenio - to reveal the brand name
for its much anticipated new car which is all set to hit the roads by year end.
Mahindra XYLO was chosen after
extensive research as it is a perfect fit with the new car's attributes. It's
trendy and contemporary, implies luxury, high fashion and technology and has
connotations of Space, planets and the future. Mahindra XYLO will soon take its
place amongst its older siblings, the iconic Scorpio and Bolero utility
vehicles.
For more information on the
latest offering from the Mahindra stable, watch this space!
Dr. Pawan Goenka, President,
Automotive Sector and Member of the Group Management Board, Mahindra &
Mahindra Ltd., makes a case for diesel as a fuel in this article which recently
appeared in The Economic Times
In the recent past, there has
been increasing opposition to the use of diesel as a fuel and the so-called
dieselisation of our vehicles. This opposition is ill-informed. In fact, there
is a clear case for greater dieselisation of our fleet along the lines of the
European Union. The only real issue with diesel today is the inability of the
government to charge a higher price for diesel fuel which would be closer to
its economic cost. However, that is no reason to condemn diesel as a vehicle
fuel.
If diesel was so bad for vehicles,
then why would the EU sell more diesel personal vehicles than petrol powered
ones? Clearly, the EU is as concerned as India about the negatives of
diesel. Why is it that 4 of the top ten models sold in the world are
diesel-powered? Why did diesel personal vehicle sales increase over 80% since
2000 in the US?
Why are diesel vehicles forecast
to make strong inroads into traditional petrol markets like the US and Japan--even
when diesel is more expensive than petrol, as in the US? Why would the US government
provide a tax incentive of up to $ 3,400 for buying a lean burn diesel
vehicle--the same kind of incentive as that provided to a hybrid vehicle?
There are three main reasons. The
first one is that a diesel engine is the most efficient internal combustion
engine amongst fossil fuels. Its inherent higher efficiency leads it to need a
lot less fuel than alternatives such as gasoline, compressed natural gas or
liquefied natural gas.
Diesel engines consume about 30%
less fuel than petrol engines. Thus, from an energy security perspective,
diesel offers a great advantage. While updated numbers for end use of diesel
are not available, it is estimated that personal diesel vehicles consumed about
3.3 million MT diesel in F-08--which is about 7% of India's diesel consumption. At 30%
higher fuel efficiency, personal diesel vehicles saved an equivalent
consumption of about 1 million MT or Rs 3,000-crore worth of fuel imports.
The second reason for diesel's
increasing global popularity is its lower greenhouse gas emissions as compared
to petrol. Diesel vehicles generate about 30% lower CO2 emissions than petrol
and on a well-to-wheel basis about the same carbon emissions as CNG.
The third reason is the
significantly improved performance of diesel vehicles with modern technology
diesel engines that provide similar power as petrol, but greater torque, making
them a pleasure to drive. And the reduced NVH makes them much less noisier.
Anyone who doubts this should drive a modern diesel vehicle. This has led to a
complete change in the way diesels are viewed.
So why are we hearing this
clamour for banning diesels in India?
There are two reasons. The first is that emissions of particulate emissions
(PM) and nitrous oxides (NOX) is higher in diesel as compared to other fossil
fuels.
However, with the improved fuel
quality and tighter emission norms, combined emission values of personal diesel
vehicles have reduced 94% between 1994 and 2005 in India. Future diesels will further
have reduced emissions. Here the issue is really not the sale of new vehicle.
The vehicular pollution in our cities is principally attributable to older
vehicles. To really reduce vehicular pollution, we need the implementation of a
strong Inspection and Maintenance program which will focus on controlling
pollution from older vehicles of all fuel types. And to control air pollution
per se, we need to also focus on non vehicle pollution sources which account
for between 65-75 % of air pollution.
The other issue is the built-in
subsidy in diesel fuel due to which the Indian Government is unable to pass on
the full cost on fears of increasing transportation costs. So how big is the
issue of subsidised diesel being used by personal vehicles? Personal diesel
vehicles account for only about 7% of India's diesel consumption. Has an
inherent fuel subsidy encouraged increased sales of diesel vehicles? The
average savings of a personal-use diesel vehicle versus a petrol vehicle in
fuel costs is about Rs 20,000 per year, but a diesel vehicle itself costs on
average about Rs 1, 00,000 more than a petrol vehicle.
So, unless such a vehicle is used
for intercity commutes or commercial purposes like a taxi, a buyer will not
choose a diesel vehicle because diesel fuel is subsidised. This is also borne
out by the fact that the proportion of diesel cars and MUVs has remained
between 17-19 % in Delhi, India's largest vehicle market,
from F03 to F-06 (being the latest year for which data is available). So let's
not make a mountain out of a molehill on this issue. We need to focus on the
real issue.
The bigger issue for the
government is diversion of diesel as a substitute fuel. Given the power
shortages we are facing, and given that normal genset fuels have increased in
price significantly more than diesel, there is an incentive of 22-25,000 MW
captive power generators to use diesel instead of fuel oils. This can be borne
out by the fact that diesel consumption increased 11% in F-08, marginally less
than petrol consumption increase, but LDO consumption declined 8% and furnace oil
consumption declined 1%.
Given a shortage of power from
the grid, LDO and FO consumption should have increased with more generation
from captive power. Some sources attribute the consumption of diesel for power
generation at about 20%. Hence, it would be beneficial to actually encourage
the use of diesel vehicles. Of course, we must also focus on fuel conservation
across the board and gradually progress towards tighter emission norms
concurrent with cleaner fuel availability. And we must implement a strong
inspection and maintenance programme for older vehicles to have the maximum
impact of reducing vehicular pollution.
Recent Comments